Handmade Cold Process Goat Milk Soap

Made in Amery, WI by Squeaky Colleen Soaps


Full size 4 oz bar

(ps. they're hand cut, so if they're small I send 2!)


Available in many limited-edition scents 


Once these scents are gone, the mighty 6 will be the NEW standard! Coming soon!


  • Unscented
  • Lavender
  • Lemon Lime
  • Eucalyptus
  • Rainstorm
  • Oatmeal Milk & Honey



What's soap made of?

Oil + Milk + Lye



Squeaky Colleen Soaps makes soap the old-fashioned way. That means rendering down pig lard and beef tallow, from local family-owned farms, (sometimes our own homestead!) for usable soap oil. Lard and tallow are paired with coconut oil and shea butter to balance out the qualities oil carries over into the final bar of soap. Examples of those qualities are, hardness, lather (bubble size!), moisture absorbsion, conditing properties & more.


Goat Milk:

Ah, the goats. Aren't they so darned cute?! Prior to 5/1/21 goat milk was sourced from my sister-in-law’s farm. Her award-winning farm operates under the name Aubrey's Acres Miniature Nigerian Dwarf Goat Farm and they all happily reside in Gilman, WI. After 5/1/21 goat milk will be sourced from The Schifsky Homestead! Right here on our farm, I will be hand milking our own milking goats. It started with sourcing milk from my sister-in-law, but now I'm sourcing the whole darned goat!



Handmade soap contains lye, also known as sodium hydroxide or, NaOH for my old Chemistry teacher Mrs. Lehnert. Squeaky Colleen Soaps always uses best practices in all aspects related to handling, purchasing, sourcing and creating soaps with lye. Locally purchased from Ace Hardware in Amery, WI.



Activated charcoal

Cocoa powder

Turmeric (slightly exfoliating)

Chlorella (will be spinach powder past 6/1/21)


Exfoliating Agent:

Poppy seeds

Coffee grounds


Florals (will be discontinued post 5/1/21)

Herbs (will be discontinued post 5/1/21)


Fragrance oil:

Sourced from Bramble Berry - Allergen report available upon request.


Essential oil:

Brand may vary, but the choice to support Wildflour in Amery, WI has not! Squeaky Colleen Soaps is devoted to purchasing essential oil through our local Amery, WI corner store, Wildflour Market.



* Soap orders are subject to change based on availability.




Photos are coming soon! If you can't wait, send Squeaky Colleen Soaps an email at: squeakycolleensoaps@gmail.com 


If you have questions regarding exfoliating agents, shape, color, etc. please email squeakycolleensoaps@gmail.com and I'll help you out as best as I can. Thank you for your patience as Squeaky Colleen Soaps undergoes these website and rebranding changes. While some things will be different, my commitment to making an excellent product has not changed. Again, THANK YOU!!

Goat Milk Soap

$5.00 Regular Price
$4.00Sale Price

    Squeaky Colleen Soaps, LLC - Amery, WI